CWGC Errors

Adding Service Record for RC DUTTA . showing correct name

http://www.rafcommands.com/galleries...g?m=1597593626

http://www.rafcommands.com/galleries...g?m=1597593629

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jagan

The airman in question Flying Officer Ramesh Chandra DATTA (130517) lost in Lancaster III ED923 Date of Crash: 09 Jul 43 97 Sqdn

This put me in touch with his family in UK, and they pointed out his correct name was Ramesh Chandra DUTTA

---

CWGC has agreed to amend their records and also order a new headstone to mark the change in name. A copy of his original RAF Service Record, GAzette Entries and finally contact directly from DUTTA's son helped seal the case.

EDIT: Corrected Name now visible https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi...tails/2777397/

http://www.rafcommands.com/database/...hp?qnum=110199

Sgt Alan Doughty Shuckburgh of 603 Squadron RAF had a twin brother P/O John Shirley Shuckburgh of 54 Squadron RAF. There appears to be an anomaly regarding these pilot brothers is that this RAF commands CWGC website shows Alan Doughty Shuckburgh as service number 904834. However, 904834 John Shirley Shuckburgh was promoted pilot office on probation on 15th January 1941, gazetted 24 March the 1941 and subsequently the London Gazette 2nd May 1941 shows Sgt J S Shuckburgh as 904834 promoted pilot office on probation (62251) to correct a misspelt surname. Again an error because future gazette enties show his service number as 62241. Is their an error on CWGC records or were there errors in gazetting John Shirley Shuckburgh?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ademottram

However, 904834 John Shirley Shuckburgh was promoted pilot office on probation on 15th January 1941, gazetted 24 March the 1941 and subsequently the London Gazette 2nd May 1941 shows Sgt J S Shuckburgh as 904834 ?

---

I think LG is in error. This link https://www.forces-war-records.co.uk...tryAward=False shows that J S Shuckburgh is 904331 and AD is 940834. The data is based on AIR78 index and I am sure you will find a manual verification of AIR78 will confirm this.

This may have been covered before

SERGEANT JOHN JOSEPH BRIMBLE
Service Number: 741563
Regiment & Unit/Ship
Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve


73 Sqdn.
Date of Death
Died 14 September 1940
Age 23 years old

• Country of ServiceUnited Kingdom
• Additional InfoSon of William Henry and Emily Annie Brimble, of Knowle, Bristol.

He comes up twice on CWGC Search Result : https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi...viceNum=741563


Individual Pages.

https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi...tails/3078900/ BROOKWOOD MILITARY CEMETERY 24. D. 13. United Kingdom

and

https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi...ails/75191361/ SITTINGBOURNE CEMETERY Old Ground. Sect. W. Grave 49. United Kingdom

Missing Service Numbers in CWGC

Column8	Column1	Column2	SERVICENUM		CWGCID	Date
Group Captain	GREENLAW	ROBERT RITCHIE	15057		2218255	18-01-43
Group Captain	WEBB	ERIC BINGHAM	16212		2234835	02-04-42
Group Captain	HODDER	FRANCIS SAMUEL	19243		2047526	06-09-43
Group Captain	TAYLOR	ALEXANDER E.	22030		2735392	20-12-45
Group Captain	GRIFFITHS	JOHN FRANCIS	24037		2726458	09-05-45
Group Captain	WHEELER	HARRY GEORGE	26004		937439	21-09-43
Group Captain	MacCALLUM	JOHN EVELYN MATIER	26039		2690116	16-10-43
Air Commodore	WAGHORN	DAVID JOHN	26046		2421638	01-04-45
Group Captain	HOMER	JOHN WOOD	26056		2178288	18-07-44
Group Captain	POWELL	JOHN ALEXANDER	26122		2224344	18-08-44
Group Captain	JORDAN	REGINALD CHARLES	28072		1082415	23-06-43
Group Captain	MATSON	BERNARD NELSON	28158		2177499	04-05-44
Group Captain	GOODHART	JACK	32077		2723246	21-01-44
Group Captain	HARDS	ALAN FREDERICK	33113		2834408	18-01-46
Group Captain	JEUDWINE	JOHN RAYMOND	33116		2651237	19-10-45
Group Captain	OGILVIE	PATRICK BRUCE BINE	36025		1803557	11-12-44
Group Captain	STANNARD	DAVID WILLIAM	36119		2701603	28-07-43

Wrong date for

http://www.rafcommands.com/database/...php?qnum=39430Sergeant Clifford John ROWLANDS (1624754)


CWGC https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi...clifford-john/ has him as Died 05 September 1944

Their own document shows it as 25 9 44
https://www.cwgc.org/find-records/fi.../#&gid=1&pid=2

Brimble there is a peculiar case. The Brookwood burial is related to remains discovered in 1980 by people excavating a wreck no 14 Sep 1980, whereas the Sittingbourne burial has an Unknown burial given a name at a later date.

Brookwood burial is dated 16 Oct 1980 but a concentration report there has a 17 Oct 1918 exhumation report mentioned.
Both burials records refer to one another.

Jagan, just wondering are you submitting these to CWGC nowadays, I have terribly slacked off due to a WW1 project I've been trying to finish this year.

Hi Dennis, Sorry, I havent submitted any records - I only did the R C Dutta submission till date. Again, no pressure or hurry - at some point we can catch up on this.

I submitted Rowlands there, its clear enough the error from their own records and I was able to send them Form 765 and 412 from the Canadian mans S/R.